Don't value opinion over evidence
This chapter is about why we should trust strong evidence, not just someone’s opinion (even if the opinion sounds confident or comes from someone who seems like an expert!) Jim Al-Khalili shows that decisions in life and science should be based on solid, reliable evidence, not just what feels right, or what we see on social media. (p. 97-113)
Straight to the point
Al-Khalili starts with everyday examples, like trusting your dentist or mechanic, not just because they say they’re an expert, but because their advice is backed up by real results and knowledge (p. 97-98).
He says it’s important to know the difference between facts, strong evidence, and just someone’s opinion.
Sometimes we think we “know” something just because it matches what we already believe or what’s trending online. (p.99)
But that’s not good enough! You have to ask:
-
What’s the real proof?
-
Is this backed up by strong evidence, or just opinions and hearsay?
He also talks about how social media makes it easier for people to spread opinions and false ideas. Many people are confident in their opinions even when they lack the evidence to support them. (p.106)
How to spot the difference? (fact/Opinion)
-
Sound evidence comes from reliable, unbiased, tested sources
-
Opinion is what someone believes, but may or may not be supported by proof
When someone makes a claim = ask for the evidence! Does it come from trusted research or is it just a feeling?
The Big Point
Don’t just accept what someone says because they sound sure, even if they’re an “expert” or have lots of followers. Always look for evidence, check sources, and stay curious. Science moves forward by being critical and checking facts (not just trusting opinions).
EXAMPLES
Book
Al-Khalili dives into conspiracy theories: like flat Earth, fake moon landings, or wild COVID-19 claims. He shows that these ideas last because people ignore solid evidence and instead only trust opinions that feel good to them. He explains why it’s important to stay polite when talking to people who believe these things, but always keep focusing back on the quality of the evidence (p.108-110)
Personal
When I started skincare a couple of years back, I bought whatever was trending on TikTok or Instagram, thinking more hype meant better results. Now, I ignore the trends and look for products with proven ingredients like niacinamide, retinol, and vitamin C. I always check if real studies or dermatologists back up the claims before I buy anything.
Bottom line
Chapter 5 teaches us:
It’s easy to trust opinions that sound certain or match our own. But real science wants strong, unbiased evidence. Ask questions, check sources, look at the proof and remember: just because something “feels” true, doesn’t mean it is. That’s how you get closer to the real facts!